Medical Billing & AR
Illustrative Scenario: AR Visibility in a Dermatology Practice
A hypothetical dermatology practice with no shared view of aging AR, and a structured way to fix it. Illustrative scenario — not a Renvara client case study.

The practice
A hypothetical four-provider dermatology practice sees a mix of medical dermatology, procedures, and a small cosmetic service line. It has an in-house billing team of three, a practice management system with standard reporting, and a clearinghouse for claims and remittances. Collections have felt "slow" for several months, but no one can say exactly why.
The problem
Claim follow-up is split across the three billing staff with no shared view of aging AR. Each person works the claims they happen to see — often the newest, because they are easiest to resolve. Older claims go unworked until someone notices them near a timely filing limit.
Specific symptoms:
- The monthly AR report is a single total with no payer breakdown
- Aging runs from the last bill date, so rebilled claims look current
- Nobody owns a specific payer, so a payer-level problem has no one watching for it
- Procedure claims held for pathology sit in a queue nobody reviews
- A handful of claims were written off last quarter for timely filing — the first sign anyone had that something was wrong
Step 1: Make AR visible
The first change is the report itself. Following the setup in the AR Aging Review Guide, the aging report is rebuilt to:
- Age from the date of service
- Separate insurance AR from patient AR
- Group by payer with 30-day buckets
- Show credit balances separately
In this hypothetical, the rebuilt report shows that two commercial payers hold a disproportionate share of the balances over 90 days — something the single total had hidden. It also shows a cluster of balances between 31 and 60 days for procedure visits, which turns out to be the pathology hold queue.
Step 2: Sample the aged claims
A billing lead pulls 15 claims over 60 days from each of the two flagged payers and records status and root cause for each. The pattern in this hypothetical:
- Payer A: most aged claims were pended for additional information — records requests mailed to an old address the payer had on file
- Payer B: a mix of modifier 25 denials on same-day E/M and procedure claims, and claims with no response at all, which turned out to be clearinghouse rejections no one was working
Neither finding is a "follow-up effort" problem. Both are upstream process problems that follow-up alone would never fix.
Step 3: Assign ownership
Instead of everyone working everything, each billing staff member is assigned a set of payers. The owner of a payer is responsible for:
- Working that payer's aged claims, oldest and highest-risk first
- Noticing when that payer's aging pattern changes
- Tracking that payer's filing and appeal deadlines
- Bringing that payer's denial trends to the monthly review
Deadline-risk claims — any within 30 days of a filing or appeal limit — go on a separate weekly list reviewed by the billing lead.
Step 4: Fix the upstream causes
Each finding from the sample gets a specific fix and an owner:
| Finding | Fix | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| Records requests going to an old address | Update the address with Payer A; add a quarterly check that payer records match current practice information | Billing lead / credentialing |
| Clearinghouse rejections not worked | Daily rejection work queue with a same-week resolution standard | Assigned payer owners |
| Modifier 25 denials | Review denied cases with providers; confirm documentation shows the separately identifiable E/M work | Billing lead with providers |
| Pathology holds aging unnoticed | Separate work queue for charges awaiting pathology, reviewed twice weekly | Coding |
The modifier 25 and pathology workflows are described in more detail in Revenue Cycle Considerations for Dermatology Practices.
Step 5: Set up recurring reporting
A one-page monthly report goes to the practice owners:
- Insurance and patient AR, with the percentage over 90 days, compared with the prior three months
- Aged AR by payer, top five
- Denials by category
- Charges held for pathology and their age
- Upstream fixes opened and their status
What would be measured
Because this is an illustrative scenario, no outcome is reported. In a real engagement of this kind, progress would be judged by indicator categories such as:
- Share of insurance AR over 90 days, trended monthly
- Aged AR concentration by payer
- Number and age of unworked rejections
- Age of charges held for pathology
- Timely filing write-offs
The expectation would be for these to move over several months as upstream fixes take hold — not immediately, and not by a predetermined amount.
Lessons from the scenario
- You can't manage what the report hides. Aging by last bill date and a single total concealed both problem payers.
- Aged AR is usually a symptom. Both payers' problems started upstream — an outdated address and unworked rejections.
- Ownership by payer creates accountability that "everyone works everything" can't.
- Specialty workflows matter. The pathology queue was a dermatology-specific source of aging that a general process missed.
For how leadership should read AR aging, see Understanding AR Aging in a Physician Practice.
Key Takeaways
- Rebuilding the aging report by payer and date of service surfaced two problem payers a single total had hidden.
- Both payers' aged AR traced back to upstream causes — an outdated address and unworked rejections.
- Payer-level ownership and a pathology hold queue addressed specialty-specific aging.
Sources & References
Regulations, program rules, and payer policies change. Educational content only — confirm current requirements with the payer, program, or your advisors before acting.
Related Renvara Solution
DermatologyWant to discuss how this applies to your practice?
Book a Practice Assessment to talk through this operational area with Renvara.
