Skip to content
Renvara Health Partners

Medical Billing & AR

Illustrative Scenario: AR Visibility in a Dermatology Practice

A hypothetical dermatology practice with no shared view of aging AR, and a structured way to fix it. Illustrative scenario — not a Renvara client case study.

Dermatology skin examination with a magnifying lens
PublishedCase Study4 min read
Illustrative scenario — not a Renvara client case study. This practice is hypothetical. The scenario describes a common operational problem and a structured way to address it. Any figures are hypothetical and are included only to make the workflow concrete; they are not results from a real engagement.

The practice

A hypothetical four-provider dermatology practice sees a mix of medical dermatology, procedures, and a small cosmetic service line. It has an in-house billing team of three, a practice management system with standard reporting, and a clearinghouse for claims and remittances. Collections have felt "slow" for several months, but no one can say exactly why.

The problem

Claim follow-up is split across the three billing staff with no shared view of aging AR. Each person works the claims they happen to see — often the newest, because they are easiest to resolve. Older claims go unworked until someone notices them near a timely filing limit.

Specific symptoms:

  • The monthly AR report is a single total with no payer breakdown
  • Aging runs from the last bill date, so rebilled claims look current
  • Nobody owns a specific payer, so a payer-level problem has no one watching for it
  • Procedure claims held for pathology sit in a queue nobody reviews
  • A handful of claims were written off last quarter for timely filing — the first sign anyone had that something was wrong

Step 1: Make AR visible

The first change is the report itself. Following the setup in the AR Aging Review Guide, the aging report is rebuilt to:

  • Age from the date of service
  • Separate insurance AR from patient AR
  • Group by payer with 30-day buckets
  • Show credit balances separately

In this hypothetical, the rebuilt report shows that two commercial payers hold a disproportionate share of the balances over 90 days — something the single total had hidden. It also shows a cluster of balances between 31 and 60 days for procedure visits, which turns out to be the pathology hold queue.

Step 2: Sample the aged claims

A billing lead pulls 15 claims over 60 days from each of the two flagged payers and records status and root cause for each. The pattern in this hypothetical:

  • Payer A: most aged claims were pended for additional information — records requests mailed to an old address the payer had on file
  • Payer B: a mix of modifier 25 denials on same-day E/M and procedure claims, and claims with no response at all, which turned out to be clearinghouse rejections no one was working

Neither finding is a "follow-up effort" problem. Both are upstream process problems that follow-up alone would never fix.

Step 3: Assign ownership

Instead of everyone working everything, each billing staff member is assigned a set of payers. The owner of a payer is responsible for:

  • Working that payer's aged claims, oldest and highest-risk first
  • Noticing when that payer's aging pattern changes
  • Tracking that payer's filing and appeal deadlines
  • Bringing that payer's denial trends to the monthly review

Deadline-risk claims — any within 30 days of a filing or appeal limit — go on a separate weekly list reviewed by the billing lead.

Step 4: Fix the upstream causes

Each finding from the sample gets a specific fix and an owner:

FindingFixOwner
Records requests going to an old addressUpdate the address with Payer A; add a quarterly check that payer records match current practice informationBilling lead / credentialing
Clearinghouse rejections not workedDaily rejection work queue with a same-week resolution standardAssigned payer owners
Modifier 25 denialsReview denied cases with providers; confirm documentation shows the separately identifiable E/M workBilling lead with providers
Pathology holds aging unnoticedSeparate work queue for charges awaiting pathology, reviewed twice weeklyCoding

The modifier 25 and pathology workflows are described in more detail in Revenue Cycle Considerations for Dermatology Practices.

Step 5: Set up recurring reporting

A one-page monthly report goes to the practice owners:

  • Insurance and patient AR, with the percentage over 90 days, compared with the prior three months
  • Aged AR by payer, top five
  • Denials by category
  • Charges held for pathology and their age
  • Upstream fixes opened and their status

What would be measured

Because this is an illustrative scenario, no outcome is reported. In a real engagement of this kind, progress would be judged by indicator categories such as:

  • Share of insurance AR over 90 days, trended monthly
  • Aged AR concentration by payer
  • Number and age of unworked rejections
  • Age of charges held for pathology
  • Timely filing write-offs

The expectation would be for these to move over several months as upstream fixes take hold — not immediately, and not by a predetermined amount.

Lessons from the scenario

  • You can't manage what the report hides. Aging by last bill date and a single total concealed both problem payers.
  • Aged AR is usually a symptom. Both payers' problems started upstream — an outdated address and unworked rejections.
  • Ownership by payer creates accountability that "everyone works everything" can't.
  • Specialty workflows matter. The pathology queue was a dermatology-specific source of aging that a general process missed.

For how leadership should read AR aging, see Understanding AR Aging in a Physician Practice.

Key Takeaways

  • Rebuilding the aging report by payer and date of service surfaced two problem payers a single total had hidden.
  • Both payers' aged AR traced back to upstream causes — an outdated address and unworked rejections.
  • Payer-level ownership and a pathology hold queue addressed specialty-specific aging.

Sources & References

Regulations, program rules, and payer policies change. Educational content only — confirm current requirements with the payer, program, or your advisors before acting.

Related Renvara Solution

Dermatology

Want to discuss how this applies to your practice?

Book a Practice Assessment to talk through this operational area with Renvara.